Skip to Content

Top 10 Most Complimented Men’s Colognes

Top 10 Most Complimented Men’s Colognes

This post may have affiliate links, meaning we earn a small commission on purchases through the links (at no extra cost to you). This does not change our opinion but does help support the site. Thank you!

Most guys want to find a cologne that fits their style and is appealing to other people as well. There are some scents you might love wearing but no one else seems quite as enamored of. Then there are others that you’re not crazy about but get people commenting and asking you what cologne you’re wearing all day long.

Top Picks at a Glance

polo black

Polo Black
Sophisticated and not overpowering during business meetings or a night out.
Check Price

Fernweh Editions Pine & Fir Candle

gucci cologne

Guilty Intense
Perfect to grab attention, and definitely a scent for the weekend.
Check Price

grey flannel cologne

Grey Flannel
A calming familiar scent that makes you feel safe and confident. 
Check Price

Of course, the ideal is to find a fragrance you enjoy wearing AND that other people enjoy smelling on you. 

We asked 10 men which of their fragrances gets the most compliments.

Top 10 Most Complimented Men’s Colognes

Polo Black by Ralph Lauren for Men*

I wear Polo Black*, I think Polo has been around so long that any of their fragrances you really can’t go wrong with.No doubt this is my go-to cologne as it smells more sophisticated and not overpowering during business meetings or a night on the town with my wife.

Mark Llano, President & CEO of Skeleton Optics, US Marine Corp (retired)Connect on Twitter|Facebook

Top 10 Most Complimented Men’s Colognes

Truefitt & Hill Aftershave Balm 1805*

I’ve been a fan of Truefitt & Hill’s grooming products for a while and was surprised with a bottle of the1805 cologne* as a gift recently.

I appreciate its clean, classic scent and always get compliments when I wear it, and questions about what it is.

Noel G, Actor and ProducerConnect on Instagram|Twitter

Top 10 Most Complimented Men’s Colognes

Calvin Klein Intense Euphoria EDT*

I wear a LOT of colognes – everything from high-end Gucci to basic Stetson.

However, the one that has gotten me the most compliments (from both men and women) is Calvin Klein’s Intense Euphoria*.

This is also my personal favorite. It’s funny because I’ve tried the regular Euphoria, and while it’s good, it doesn’t garner nearly the amount of praise at the Intense Euphoria does. 

James Pollard, on LinkedIn|Twitter

Top 10 Most Complimented Men’s Colognes

 Santal 33 Perfume Oil*

I wanted to recommend Santal 33* Parfum from Le Labo.

It’s the one fragrance everyone has loved on me, both men and women.I’m a fan of the smokiness and masculinity it has, without being too overwhelming.

Jeremy Lindy, Connect on Twitter 

Top 10 Most Complimented Men’s Colognes

Gucci Guilty Intense EDT*

Gucci Guilty Intense* is by far, the most complimented cologne I wear it also is the one that lasts the longest.

I’ve had so many strangers come up to me and ask what I’m wearing, it’s ridiculous. If you’re looking to grab attention, this one is a sure way of doing so.

This one is more so a scent for the weekend, as I feel in an office setting, it may be a bit overpowering.

Ross Walker SmithConnect onTwitter|Instagram 

Top 10 Most Complimented Men’s Colognes

Geoffrey Beene Grey Flannel for Men*

Grey Flannel* is a calming familiar scent. This makes my customers feel safe and confident. Though the fragrance is not entirely a floral, the unusual violet note is the undisputed star of the olfactory pyramid.

When paired with citrus, oakmoss and sandalwood, gone are the candy-sweet connotations of violets, and hello warm, comfy sweater. The citrus brightens the composition while the oakmoss and patchouli ground and tame it. 

Howard Wiggins, Interior Designer Connect on Facebook

Top 10 Most Complimented Men’s Colognes

Thomas Clipper Coast Cologne

I wear Coast by Thomas Clipper. People constantly ask what I’m wearing when I have this on.

Coast is part of the UNITE collection the company is dedicated to responsibly sourcing their products. The UNITE collection is designed to be used together.

So while Coast is fresh and sporty with citrus notes all on its own, it can also be blended with the other two scents in the collection, City or Country, to change the profile. 

Caleb Gibson,CEO/Founder Carrot Krate/Connect on Facebook

Top 10 Most Complimented Men’s Colognes

Faberge Brut Cologne Splash for Men*

Brut Cologne* does the trick for me (and more importantly for my wife!) Keith Guernsey, Author*

Thanks to all the guys for weighing in on their scents.Love seeing the mix of new niche fragrances and the classics.If you’re still looking for your signature scent that will get everyone asking what you’re wearing, these fragrances are a great place to start.

Fernweh Summer Candles