Skip to Content

4 Best Niche Cologne Brands for Men to Try

If you’ve visited any niche fragrance store recently, you’d be blown away by the sheer quantity available.

This post may have affiliate links, meaning we earn a small commission on purchases through the links (at no extra cost to you). This does not change our opinion but does help support the site. Thank you!
At A Glance: Our Top 4 Male Niche Cologne Brands

The diversity on offer can be mind-blowing and very intimidating. This is where this article on the best niche cologne brands comes in handy.


  • A brand for modern gentlemen
  • More than 70 fragrances
  • Has a touch of tradition
Frederic Malle Music For A While
  • A lavender fragrance
  • Slightly sweet
  • Light and airy
D.S & Durga
  • Modern niche cologne
  • Fig-dominant fragrance
  • Small-batch fragrances and quirky story-telling

Decline of Celebrity and Designer Fragrances

The fragrance market ain’t what it used to be and niche fragrances are on the rise. The steady decline of the celebrity fragrance category is gathering pace. Designer fragrances that used to fly off the shelves are increasingly being discounted.

The numbers below speak for themselves. These figures are for the world’s largest fragrance market, the USA. But these are international trends, according to industry analysts NPD Group, The Business of Fashion and Perfumer & Flavorist. 

Amid all the number-crunching, there’s a discernible shift to the best niche cologne brands. They have added almost $250 million to the fragrance market since 2014.

Changes in the Fragrance Market

66% the decline of the celebrity fragrance market in department stores from 2011-2014.

6% the drop in overall fragrance sales from 2015 to 2016.

1%  the sales growth of prestige fragrances.

Rise of Niche and Indie Fragrances

There are simple reasons why niche fragrances have taken off in the past 10 years or so. Many consumers got tired of designer fragrances increasingly starting to smell the same and they wanted an element of individuality and to feel special.

If you want a fragrance that’s unusual and sometimes pushes the boundaries of what a perfume should be, you’ll find it in the niche category. This is not to say that designer fragrances are all the same and therefore on the way out.

For the purpose of this feature, I will use the term niche to include indie and artisanal fragrances, as they too have limited distribution. This is my definition of niche fragrances.

best niche colognes

Best Niche Cologne Brands Worth a Try

I’ve selected four brands worth exploring: Creed, Penhaligon’s, Editions de Parfums Frederic Malle and D.S. & Durga. They all reflect the best niche cologne brands. I could list many more, but these are a good start.

niche cologne brands for men

Creed Men's Cologne

Heritage is an important factor in the perfume business and this Paris-based company has no shortage of it. Founded in 1760 by as a tailoring business, today Creed is known for its high-quality fragrances with a price tag to match.

After its founding, it became a favorite among Europe’s monarchs, with numerous commissions and royal warrants to its name. Creed starting selling its fragrances to the public in 1970. The sixth-generation Olivier Creed is currently the in-house perfumer.

Highly recommended: Creed Aventus EDP has a huge cult following, bordering on the religious. But there are also other very worthwhile Creed fragrances to be on the lookout for.

There are many listed notes for Creed Imperial Millesime Imperial EDP, but its standout ingredient is ambergris. This rare and costly ingredient is a by-product of the digestive system of the sperm whale. It gives this fragrance a magnificent musky smell.

best niche colognes

Penhaligon's Men's Cologne

Another heritage brand, this UK fragrance house, holding some of the best niche cologne brands, was founded in 1870 by William Penhaligon in London. What started out as barbershop is today known as the brand for modern gentlemen who appreciate a touch of tradition.

There are more than 70 fragrances in Penhaligon’s catalog, including Penhaligon's No. 33, The Impudent Cousin Matthew and Juniper Sling EDT (2011). So expect to be spoilt for choice.

Highly recommended: For something more recent, the Portraits Collection offers the brand’s balance of modernity and tradition. There are already 13 fragrances in the collection.

Penhaligon’s Much Ado About The Duke EDP gets my vote, though - it's most definitely one of the best niche colognes available. It features an irresistible combination of rose, leather, and gin and tonic notes.

niche cologne brands for men

Editions De Parfums Frederic Malle

Paris-born Frederic Frederic’s grandfather founded the illustrious Christian Dior Parfums. In 2000, he decided to launch his own niche fragrance company, which would focus on complete creative freedom and the best ingredients available for the perfumers.

All the fragrances have the name of the perfumer on the bottle, which is still quite revolutionary. Over the years, numerous modern classics have been launched by Frederic Malle, including Pierre Bourdon’s French Lover EDP, Maurice Roucel’s Musc Ravageur EDP and Dominique Ropion’s Vetiver Extraordinaire EDP. So rest assured, quality is always at a premium.

Highly recommended: Love lavender in your fragrance? Then you can’t go wrong with Carlos Benam’s Music For A While, which was released earlier this year. It’s pure compliment-bait, thanks to its mix of pineapple, fruit, patchouli, caramel and vanilla notes.

Yes, it’s slightly sweet, but the master Benaim keeps it admirably light and airy.

niche cologne brands for men

D.S. & Durga

Forget the completely inappropriate hipster label, this NYC-based perfumery was founded by David Seth and Kavi Moltz in 2007.

Their company offers a thoroughly modern take on niche fragrances with small-batch fragrances and quirky story-telling. There’s huge diversity in their 64 fragrances, ranging from Burnt Citrus to Rose Atlantic.

Highly recommended: Named after the classic Pixies song, Debaser conjures up all sorts of boozy rock n roll connotations.

Instead, you get a fig-dominant fragrance that’s superb from start to finish. Iris, coconut milk and tonka bean notes also feature in the beautiful mix. One of the most special and best niche colognes out there.

Pin On Pinterest

4 Best Niche Cologne Brands

Richard Goller is a fragrance and grooming blogger. His blog is called Fragroom. A senior editor with 20 years' experience, his blog allows him to combine two of his passions: engaging content and the always-intriguing world of fragrances. When he isn't blogging, you'll find Richard indulging in his newly found passion for balcony gardening.