Skip to Content

4 Best Shaving Creams for Sensitive Skin: Real Men's Choice

Dive into the realm of shaving creams designed with sensitivity in mind and discover the top choices of real men who understand the importance of a comfortable shave. We've curated recommendations from industry leaders, founders, and CEOs to help you find shaving products for sensitive skin. 

This post may have affiliate links, meaning we earn a small commission on purchases through the links (at no extra cost to you). This does not change our opinion but does help support the site. Thank you!

From a natural shaving cream to a product tailored for dry skin - explore the selections that have earned the stamp of approval from those who know what it takes to get a smooth and irritation-free shaving experience.

Best Shaving Cream for Sensitive Skin

jack black best shaving cream

Best Lather

I recommend using the Jack Black Supreme Cream Triple Cushion Shave Lather. It's a skin-friendly shaving cream designed to give a smooth and comfortable shave for men with sensitive skin. More lather, better shave. 

It has a luxurious texture that creates a rich lather, allowing the razor to glide effortlessly across your skin. It contains three protective layers—I will say cushions—that help to minimize irritation and razor burn. The first cushion lifts the hair, the second ensures a close shave, and the third protects your skin. 

Talking about the ingredients, it has macadamia nut oil and glycerin, which help to moisturize and soothe the skin, leaving it feeling soft and refreshed. Give it a try and experience the perfect shave.

- Jean Christophe Gabler, Founder, Yogi Times

best shaving cream for sensitive skin

Best Natural Shaving Cream

I have incredibly sensitive skin and have never been able to find a single over-the-counter shave cream or gel that works for me. I've tried everything from $2 cans of knock-off Barbasol to $40 ultra-luxury stuff from Ulta Beauty. Nothing has worked. 

That is why I started making my own cream out of 100% natural ingredients. I use shea butter, organic coconut oil, jojoba oil, and a couple of drops of essential oil (preferably patchouli). It only takes a few minutes to make, costs less than $10 for a batch, and is so incredibly smooth and neutral. It has been a godsend for my sensitive skin, finding this all-natural, organic recipe.

- John Ross, CEO, Test Prep Insight

cremo best shaving cream

Best Soothing

Men coping with sensitivity, particularly on the face or in private areas, are recommended to use Cremo Cooling Shave Cream. This cream is infused with calming elements such as menthol and tea tree oil, delivering a cooling effect that soothes irritation and reduces redness. It proves suitable for those with acne-prone, extremely sensitive, or dry and itchy skin.

The distinct formula works to minimize friction, ensuring a shave that is both smooth and comfortable. Optimal shaving for exceptionally sensitive skin involves utilizing a sharp, clean razor and shaving in the direction of hair growth to diminish irritation. Regarding shaving gel or foam for individuals with sensitivity, a gel is often favored for its increased hydration and an additional layer of skin protection, ensuring a gentle and nourishing shaving experience.

- Mark Fong, General Manager, CEO, Goneng Lighting

Best for Oily or Dry Skin

If you have acne-prone skin—consider Neutrogena Men Skin Clearing Shave Cream with salicylic acid, but do a patch test first. Extremely sensitive or dry skin can benefit from Aveeno Therapeutic Shave Gel as well.

Cremo Cooling Shave Cream offers quite an ultra-smooth glide. The product is also free from harsh chemicals, making it suitable for everyone out there looking for a shaving cream that's gentle on sensitive skin.

Shaving with the grain reduces irritation for sensitive skin, and both gel and foam can work well.

- Russell Noga, CEO,

Mastering the Art of Shaving with Ultra-Sensitive Skin

Shaving super sensitive skin means you need a gentle and careful approach to minimize irritation and discomfort. Here are some methods and products you’ll want to incorporate in your shaving routine if you have very sensitive skin:


Warm Water: Before shaving, use warm water to soften the hair and open up the pores. Maybe even shave after a warm shower prior to shaving.

Pre-Shave Oil: Applying a pre-shave oil can give you an extra layer of lubrication, reducing friction when you’re shaving.

Choosing the Right Products:

Sensitive Skin Shaving Cream or Gel: Opt for one of the shaving creams or gels specifically formulated for sensitive skin above or find another. These products often have moisturizing and soothing ingredients to minimize irritation.

Fragrance-Free Products: Fragrance-free or hypoallergenic products are best to avoid potential skin reactions.

Before incorporating new shaving products into your routine, do a patch test to make sure they don't cause adverse reactions.

Shaving Technique:

Sharp, Clean Razor: Use a sharp and clean razor for a smooth shave to avoid hair or skin tugging or pulling.

Shave in the Direction of Hair Growth: Shave in the direction of hair growth to reduce irritation. Avoid multiple passes over the same area–this can lead to increased sensitivity.

Post-Shave Care:

Cold Water Rinse: Finish the shave with a cold water rinse to soothe the skin and close the pores.

Alcohol-Free Aftershave: Choose an alcohol-free, soothing aftershave to hydrate and calm the skin without bringing on more irritation to your skin.

Regular Maintenance:

Regular Razor Replacement: Change your razor blade regularly to maintain sharpness and prevent irritation.

Moisturize: Use a gentle, hypoallergenic moisturizer to keep the skin hydrated and prevent dryness.

Remember that individual preferences and skin sensitivities vary, so it may take some experimentation to find the combination of products and techniques that work best for your sensitive skin.

Karina is the Managing Editor at Dapper Confidential. She helps us establish topics that interest our readers and she's also the conduit in our editorial process. Originally from Sydney city, she's now appreciating a slower paced life with her fur babies.