Skip to Content

What is the Best Aftershave for Acne Prone Skin?

Using aftershave is the best method to rehydrate your skin after shaving. It helps soothe the skin, prevent razor burn, and can add a subtle fragrance to your routine. When you have acne prone skin, choosing what products you'll put on your face can be tedious. 

This post may have affiliate links, meaning we earn a small commission on purchases through the links (at no extra cost to you). This does not change our opinion but does help support the site. Thank you!

You'll want to choose products that are sensitive to acne prone skin and ones that won't cause inflammation. We've rounded up the best aftershave for acne prone skin if you're on the hunt for a great product.

Our Top Picks For Best Aftershave For Acne Prone Skin

If you're on the hunt for an aftershave that works well with your skin, here are our top picks for the best aftershaves for acne prone skin. 

Best Aftershave For Acne Prone Skin: NIVEA MEN Sensitive Post Shave Balm

Best Overall

We chose the Nivea Men Sensitive Post Shave Balm as our best overall pick. This product fights all five critical signs of shaving irritation: burning, dryness, tightness, and more. The formula is more like a lotion, so it feels extra moisturizing for those with sensitive skin. 

PROS: There's no alcohol in the product, so it won't dry or damage your freshly shaven skin. 

CONS: It might be too oily for those with naturally oily skin. 

  • Star Rating: 4.5/5
  • Key Ingredients: Chamomile and vitamin E 
  • Value: 3.3 oz  
  • Scent: Light 

Shop More Online

Lather and Wood After-shave Balm

Best Runner-Up

A close second to our best overall is Lather and Wood Aftershave Balm. We love this product because it's paraben-free, alcohol-free, and lacks harmful minerals that can irritate freshly shaven skin. It's not greasy and works well on almost all skin types

PROS: You only get two ounces, but a little bit goes a long way with this product making it worth your money.  

CONS: The fragrance is a little overpowering for those sensitive to smells. 

  • Star Rating: ⅘ 
  • Key Ingredients: Shea butter, sandalwood, and aloe
  • Value: 2 oz
  • Scent: Sandalwood 

Shop More Online

Bee Bald HEAL Post-Shave Healing Balm

Best for On The Go

The Bee Bald travel size option is a great product when you need an aftershave on the go. Both men and women love this product because it is the best aftershave for razor bumps and other irritations. They only use all-natural ingredients, making it safe for everyone and all skin types. 

PROS: The product can be used all over the body where you shave, not just your face. 

CONS: While adding pollen can help combat allergies, it might irritate sensitive skin individuals. 

  • Star Rating: 2.5/5 
  • Key Ingredients: Pollen and honey
  • Value: 2 oz
  • Scent: Fresh 

Shop More Online

Bump Patrol Original Formula After Shave Bump Treatment Serum

Best for Ingrown Hair Prevention 

Along with acne, if you suffer from ingrown hairs, you'll appreciate Original Aftershave Treatment from Bump Patrol. We love that it's unscented because that's helpful for some people and that it helps prevent ingrown hairs, even on armpits, thanks to its unique formula. 

PROS: It's dermatologist-tested on all parts of the body after shaving. 

CONS: The addition of alcohol can be very irritating to some people after shaving. 

  • Star Rating: ⅖ 
  • Key Ingredients: Alcohol and water 
  • Value: 1.9 oz
  • Scent: Unscented 

Shop More Online

COOCHY Intimate After Shave Protection Moisturizer Plus

Best for Women

Men aren't the only ones with acne prone skin that could benefit from an aftershave. For women, we suggest the Coochy Plus Intimate Aftershave formula. Men can use it too, but it's geared more toward women. 

PROS: It's natural alcohol, paraben, and animal-testing-free product. 

CONS: It's not tested on where you'd shave your face. 

  • Star Rating: ⅗ 
  • Key Ingredients: Cucumber extract, sage leaf extract, and lavender extract 
  • Value: 4 oz
  • Scent: Lavender and sage 

Shop More Online

Proraso After Shave Lotion for Men

Best Fragrance

A great product from Proraso with the best fragrance is their Aftershave Lotion for Men with eucalyptus oil. We love the menthol in the product as it helps cool down the skin faster without irritating it. The consistency between a gel and liquid allows it to glide on easily. 

Pros: The cooling features are ideal without feeling like you're burning your face. 

Cons: It might not provide immediate relief like other aftershaves. 

  • Star Rating: 3.5/5
  • Ingredients: Eucalyptus oil, menthol, and witch hazel
  • Value: 20 oz
  • Scent: Eucalyptus 

Shop More Online

Art of Shaving Sandalwood Balm

Best for All Day Soothing

Not all aftershaves provide a soothing feeling all day, but The Art of Shaving Aftershave Balm does. It pulls off this because it's an aftershave and moisturizer rolled into one product. It has all the cooling properties you want in an aftershave while keeping your skin soft all day. 

PROS: The balm consistency is excellent for all-day moisture and soothing. 

CONS: If you have oily skin, the aftershave might cause more acne. 

  • Star Rating: 3.5/5
  • Key Ingredients: Jojoba seed oil and shea butter 
  • Value: 3.3 oz
  • Scent: Sandalwood 

Shop More Online

Aqua Velva After Shave

Best Budget-Friendly Option

If you're on a budget but want an aftershave that is best for acne prone skin, the Aqua Velva Aftershave is a good option. It's more of your classic, liquid aftershave, but it does well for those with acne prone skin. 

PROS: It's the most affordable that won't cause you to break out in pimples. 

CONS: It will cool your face, but you won't feel a moisturizing sensation. 

  • Star Rating: 2.5/5
  • Key Ingredients: Alcohol, methol, and water 
  • Value: 7 oz
  • Scent: Classic American

Shop More Online

Paula’s Choice Aftershave

Best Splurge

For those who aren't worried about the price, Paula's Choice Aftershave is terrific for those with acne or acne prone skin. It's great for those sensitive to smell because it's an unscented aftershave. We think it's also the best aftershave for electric shaver

PROS: It's entirely cruelty-free and paraben-free. 

CONS: It can take several rounds of shaving to see a difference. 

  • Star Rating: ⅗ 
  • Key Ingredients: Benzoyl peroxide, water, and sodium hydroxide  
  • Value: 4 oz
  • Scent: None

Shop More Online

Proraso After Shave Balm for Men

Best for Sensitive Skin

Proraso's Aftershave Balm with Oatmeal is the best aftershave for sensitive skin. It's 95% all-natural and won't harm your skin. Even if you don't have sensitive skin, we're sure you'll appreciate this Proraso aftershave. 

PROS: It's alcohol and paraben-free, so it won't cause excessive irritation. 

CONS: Some people dislike the scent. 

  • Star Rating: ⅘ 
  • Key Ingredients: Green tea and oatmeal extract 
  • Value: 3.4 oz
  • Scent: Green tea

Shop More Online

Should You Use Aftershave if You Have Acne or Acne Prone Skin?

Some say you shouldn't, but hydration is essential to prevent acne.

man applying aftershave

If you have acne prone skin, you can use aftershave, but you'll want to choose one that's sensitive and suitable for your skin type. 

Does Aftershave Cause Acne?

Some aftershave can cause acne because of the build-up of oils in your pores. 

Final Thoughts

Using aftershave is a great way to soothe your skin after shaving. For those with acne prone skin, choosing an aftershave needs to be done carefully so you don't irritate your skin further.

This list will help you find the best aftershave for acne prone skin to prevent extra acne and keep your skin smooth and free of irritation.

Pin On Pinterest

Best Aftershave for Acne Prone Skin

Born and raised in Austin, David is a dedicated writer and avid fragrance lover. When he's not trying out perfumes, he enjoys traveling and exploring new restaurants.